When Therapy Isn't Working

Most advice about therapy is about starting. Far less is written about the part that comes months later, when you have been going for a while and something is off — sessions feel repetitive, you leave without much to think about, or you notice you are relieved when one gets canceled.

That feeling is worth taking seriously. It is also worth slowing down on, because "this isn't working" can mean several quite different things, and they call for different responses.

How do I tell a hard stretch from a bad fit?

Both feel like stalling. Some things that can sit behind it:

• You are working on something painful. A stretch of therapy that touches difficult material can feel worse than the weeks before it. That is worth naming out loud with your therapist rather than reading as a verdict on the work.
• The goal has quietly changed. What you came in for may not be what matters most now, and the sessions may still be pointed at the original thing.
• The pace or cadence is wrong. Sessions every other week can be too sparse to build on. Weekly can be too much to absorb.
• The approach is not landing. Ways of working differ a great deal, and a style that suits one person can feel unhelpful to another.
• It is genuinely not a fit. Sometimes two people just do not work well together, and no amount of persistence changes that.

Only the last one is really about switching. The others are about adjusting — and you cannot tell which you are in without saying something.

Should I tell my therapist it isn't working?

This is the step people skip, usually because it feels rude or because it seems easier to just stop booking. It is neither rude nor unusual. Clinicians expect this conversation and are trained for it.

You do not need a diagnosis of the problem, just an honest opening:

• "I have been feeling like we are going over the same ground. Can we talk about that?"
• "I am not sure what I am working toward anymore."
• "The last few sessions have felt harder. Is that expected?"
• "Can we revisit what we set out to do and see if it still fits?"

Then pay attention to what comes back. A useful response takes the question seriously, asks you more about it, and leads to something changing — a revised focus, a different approach, a shift in cadence. A response that leaves you feeling managed, dismissed, or as though you have caused a problem is itself information.

Give a genuine adjustment a few sessions before judging it. Give a non-response much less.

When should I change therapists?

There is no checklist that settles this, but people often describe some version of the following:

• You have raised it clearly and nothing changed.
• You find yourself editing what you say to keep the session comfortable.
• You do not feel you can be honest with this person about something embarrassing.
• You have lost confidence that they understand what you came in for.
• Practical things keep going wrong — repeated rescheduling, a cadence you cannot sustain.

None of these mean therapy failed you, and none of them require an elaborate justification. Changing clinicians is an ordinary thing that happens in ordinary care.

One exception is worth stating plainly: if you feel you are getting worse rather than stuck, do not sit with it while you decide about fit. Tell your therapist, and tell your doctor. That is a reason to get support quickly, not a reason to work through a decision on your own.

How do I switch therapists without losing progress?

The real cost of changing therapists is the retelling — the sense of resetting to session one. Some of that is unavoidable, but much of it is not.

• Do not disappear. A final session, or even a short message saying you are stopping, gives you a cleaner ending and a chance to hear what they would suggest looking for next.
• Ask what they would recommend. Clinicians usually have a view on what approach or what kind of practitioner might suit you better, and it is often the single most useful thing you get out of ending.
• Write down what you learned. What helped, what did not, what you want to be different. Half a page is plenty and it makes the first session with someone new far more productive.
• Ask about your records. You can ask what notes exist and how they can be shared with a new clinician. What is possible depends on the practice and on where you are, so ask rather than assume.
• Try to line up the next one before you stop. A gap of a few weeks is normal; a gap of several months tends to become permanent.

Your new clinician does not need the whole history in session one. "I worked with someone for six months, here is what we covered and here is why I moved" is a strong start. Our guide to what happens in a first session covers the rest of it.

When the problem is not the therapist

Sometimes the thing that is not working is everything around the session. Cost that has become hard to sustain, an appointment slot that keeps colliding with work, a commute that makes you cancel, or nothing happening in the six days between sessions.

These are worth separating out, because switching clinicians does not fix any of them. Changing the format might — moving between video and in person, moving to a time you can actually keep, or revisiting cost directly rather than quietly tapering off. Ask about a sliding scale if the rate is the issue; most practices will not raise it unless you do.

How this works at OpenCove

If you are working with an OpenCove clinician and it is not fitting, tell us and we'll talk through options, including a different clinician where one is available in your state. You do not need to explain yourself at length.

OpenCove offers therapy and counselling, and physiotherapy, by telehealth to members in Texas, Florida, Colorado and New Mexico. Care starts with a consultation, where we quote self-pay rates before any care begins. We don't bill insurance, and we don't offer psychiatry or medication management. If you need either, your primary care doctor is a good starting point.

Tell us what is not working and we will help you sort out which part of it to change.

---

If you need support right now: call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, or text HOME to 741741 for the Crisis Text Line. Both are free, confidential, and available 24/7.